How Internal Auditors Can Use the DVMS to Strengthen Cyber Risk Scoping and Testing

How Internal Auditors Can Use the DVMS to Strengthen Cyber Risk Scoping and Testing

Internal audit has become one of the most critical functions in organizations navigating cybersecurity threats, digital transformation, regulatory pressure, and increasing expectations around operational resilience and digital trust.

Historically, internal audit approached technology and cybersecurity primarily through compliance-driven, control-based testing. However, as digital ecosystems become increasingly interconnected and risk becomes more dynamic, internal auditors must adapt their methods.

The Digital Value Management System (DVMS) offers a modern, systems-based approach that enables auditors to understand better and test how people, processes, technology, and governance interact to produce—or fail to produce—digital value outcomes. By leveraging the DVMS architecture, internal auditors can enhance scoping, strengthen testing, improve assurance quality, and deliver insights that are more closely aligned with executive and board expectations.

Understanding DVMS as a Scoping and Testing Framework

The DVMS is built on the integration of three foundational components: Governance Intent, Operational Capability, and Assurance Evidence. These components do not operate independently—they form a closed-loop system that ensures digital programs such as Cybersecurity, GRC, ITSM, and AI are adequately governed, executed effectively, and validated with credible evidence. For internal auditors, this architecture provides a natural structure for scoping audits, identifying systemic weaknesses, and designing tests that evaluate not only the existence of controls but also their effectiveness and outcome reliability.

Traditional audit scoping often begins with a risk register, a set of policies, or a list of controls mapped against frameworks. The DVMS enhances this by enabling auditors to start with a more fundamental question: Is the organization’s digital work system designed in a way that can produce the outcomes leadership expects? This systems-level perspective leads to deeper, more accurate scoping and prevents auditors from spending time on controls that may exist but are irrelevant to real-world outcomes.

Using Governance Intent to Define Audit Scope

Governance Intent represents the organization’s formal expectations, including policies, standards, risk appetite, procedural requirements, and decision-making structures. For internal auditors, Governance Intent becomes one of the most potent tools for scoping. Instead of focusing solely on whether policies exist, auditors can evaluate alignment between governance intent and business reality.

Internal auditors should begin by reviewing key documents, including cybersecurity strategies, risk appetite statements, resilience plans, policy frameworks, and program charters. These documents tell the story of what executives believe is happening. Audit scoping, then, should compare this intended design against operational execution. When governance intent is unclear, incomplete, contradictory, or outdated, auditors can immediately identify areas of scope, such as unclear roles, inadequate oversight, or policy gaps. If governance intent is strong, auditors can scope their testing to verify whether operations and assurance mechanisms align with those intentions.

This gives internal audit a clear, risk-based structure: an audit where governance intent and operational reality diverge.

Evaluating Operational Capability as a Basis for Testing

Operational Capability encompasses the people, processes, technologies, and culture that are responsible for executing work. Internal auditors can utilize this layer of the DVMS to pinpoint areas where testing will have the most significant impact.

Capabilities can be assessed through interviews, workflow analysis, system walkthroughs, and review of process documentation. Instead of only checking whether a control exists, auditors should examine whether the underlying capability can consistently deliver the expected outcome. For instance, a policy may require timely patching. Still, if capacity, skill sets, workflow design, or tool integration are inadequate, the capability cannot meet the intent—even if controls appear to exist on paper.

Internal auditors can use DVMS to classify operational weaknesses, such as:

• misaligned processes
• unclear responsibilities
• inadequate skills or staffing
• outdated technology
• cultural resistance
• fragmented workflows
• siloed teams

Testing should then focus on verifying whether these capabilities can meet expectations, especially under stress, which is a core principle of DVMS.

Using Assurance Evidence to Validate Outcomes

The third DVMS component—Assurance Evidence—is where the internal audit’s role becomes most visible. Assurance Evidence includes metrics, reports, dashboards, logs, artifacts, and documents that demonstrate whether expected outcomes are being achieved.

Internal auditors can use the DVMS intelligence-driven model to test:

1. Does the organization generate evidence that is complete, accurate, and reliable?
2. Does the evidence meaningfully demonstrate whether outcomes are being achieved?
3. Is evidence produced consistently and used by leadership to make decisions?

A common failure uncovered through DVMS-informed testing is that organizations generate large volumes of data but lack a system for transforming that data into actionable insights. Internal auditors can scope and test whether assurance evidence is:

• aligned to governance intent
• relevant to operational capability
• trustworthy under stress
• used by executives and boards to evaluate program performance

If assurance evidence cannot be trusted, the organization cannot assure outcomes—regardless of how strong its governance or operations appear.

Applying DVMS to Risk-Based Scoping

One of the most significant benefits the DVMS brings to internal audit is a more accurate method for scoping risk. Instead of scoping based solely on frameworks, auditors can scope based on systemic alignment.

Internal auditors should begin by mapping:

• governance expectations
• operational capability
• evidence reliability

Where any of the three are misaligned, the DVMS identifies these as risk concentration points. These points should become audit scope priorities because they represent areas most likely to result in operational failures, regulatory non-compliance, and reputational harm.

Scoping based on DVMS also prevents redundant audits, reduces audit fatigue, and increases the likelihood that audit findings accurately reflect the organization’s ability to produce measurable, resilient, and trusted outcomes.

Using DVMS to Design More Effective Tests

Once the scope is established, internal auditors can use DVMS to develop more impactful tests. These tests should examine:

• whether governance intent is clear, current, and communicated
• whether operational capabilities can meet those expectations
• whether assurance evidence accurately reflects actual performance
• whether resilience practices can withstand stress or disruption

Testing moves away from “check-the-box” control verification toward evaluating the system’s ability to deliver outcomes. This shift is valuable for leaders, as it aligns audit reporting with board and regulatory expectations.

Enhancing Audit Reporting With DVMS

Ultimately, internal auditors can utilize DVMS principles to structure audit reporting in a manner that resonates with executives and boards. Findings should be categorized according to:

• governance intent gaps
• operational capability deficiencies
• assurance evidence weaknesses
• cultural or behavioral issues

This structure improves clarity, enhances board oversight, and drives more actionable remediation.

Conclusion

The DVMS provides internal auditors with a robust, modern framework for scoping and testing digital programs. By aligning audit methods to Governance Intent, Operational Capability, and Assurance Evidence, auditors can identify systemic weaknesses, validate real-world outcomes, and provide executives and boards with meaningful, evidence-based assurance. Instead of auditing controls in isolation, auditors using DVMS evaluate whether the entire system can deliver the value, resilience, and trust the organization promises. This makes internal audit not just a compliance checker, but a strategic enabler of digital success.

About the Author

Rick Lemieux
Co-Founder and Chief Product Officer of the DVMS Institute

Rick has 40+ years of passion and experience creating solutions to give organizations a competitive edge in their service markets. In 2015, Rick was identified as one of the top five IT Entrepreneurs in the State of Rhode Island by the TECH 10 awards for developing innovative training and mentoring solutions for boards, senior executives, and operational stakeholders.

Digital Value Management System® (DVMS)

Digital Value Management System® (DVMS)

An Adaptive, Culture-Driven Governance, Resilience, Assurance, and Accountability (GRAA) System

A Digital Value Management System (DVMS) enables organizations of any size or complexity to operate with an adaptive, culture-driven Governance, Resilience, Assurance, and Accountability (GRAA) system that ensures Cybersecurity, GRC, ITSM, and AI programs consistently deliver the outcomes expected by boards, executive leaders, and government regulators—even under stress.

Through a structured, intelligence-driven integration of Governance Intent, Operational Capability, and Assurance Evidence, the DVMS provides executive leadership and auditors with explicit confirmation that digital transformation initiatives are delivering their intended outcomes.

Through its MVC, CPD, 3D Knowledge, and FastTrack Models, the DVMS operationalizes a:

• Governance Overlay system that unifies strategy, assurance, and operations
• Behavioral Engine that transforms how organizations think, decide, and act in uncertainty
• Learning System that measures, adapts, and innovates culture over time.

DVMS White Papers

• The Assurance Mandate –  Moving to Evidence-Based Operational Resilience
• Assurance in Action –  Turning Policy into Organizational Capability
• Governance By Assurance –  A Systems Approach to Outcome-Based Regulation

DVMS Organizational Benefits

Instead of replacing existing operational frameworks, the DVMS elevates them—connecting and contextualizing their data into actionable intelligence that validates performance and exposes the reasons behind unmet outcomes.

By adopting a DVMS, organizations are positioned to:

• Maintain Operational Stability Amidst Constant Digital Disruption
• Deliver Digital Value and Trust Across A Digital Ecosystem
• Satisfy Critical Regulatory and Certification Requirements
• Leverage Cyber Resilience as a Competitive Advantage

DVMS Leadership Benefits

• For the CEO, the DVMS provides a clear line of sight between digital operations, business performance, and strategic outcomes—turning governance and resilience into enablers of growth and innovation rather than cost centers.
• For the Board of Directors, the DVMS provides ongoing assurance that the organization’s digital assets, operations, and ecosystem are governed, protected, and resilient—supported by evidence-based reporting that directly links operational integrity to enterprise value and stakeholder trust.
• For the CIO, CRO, CISO, and Auditors: an integrated, adaptive, and culture-driven governance and assurance management system that enhances digital business performance, resilience, trust, and accountability

DVMS Institute Certified Training Programs

DVMS Cyber Resilience Awareness Training

The DVMS Cyber Resilience Awareness training teaches all employees the fundamentals of digital business, its associated risks, the NISTCSF, and their role as part of a culture responsible for protecting digital business performance, resilience, and trust. This investment fosters a culture that is prepared to transform systemic cyber risks into operational resilience.

DVMS NISTCSF Foundation Certification Training

The DVMS NISTCSF Foundation certification training course teaches ITSM, GRC, Cybersecurity, and Business professionals a detailed understanding of the NIST Cybersecurity Framework and its role in an integrated, adaptive, and culture-driven governance and assurance management system that drives digital business performance, resilience, trust, and accountability.

DVMS Cyber Resilience Practitioner Certification Training

The DVMS Practitioner certification training course teaches ITSM, GRC, Cybersecurity, and Business professionals how to assess, design, implement, operationalize, and continually innovate a Digital Value Management System® program that integrates fragmented frameworks such as NIST, ITSM, and GRC into an adaptive and culture-driven governance and assurance system that enhances digital business performance, resilience, trust, and accountability.

DVMS Brochures

• Company Brochure
• Product Brochure
• Company Presentation

DVMS Explainer Videos

• Architecture Video: David Moskowitz explains the DVMS System
• Case Study Video: Dr. Joseph Baugh Shares His DVMS Story.
• Overlay Model – What is an Overlay Model
• MVC ZX Model – Powers the CPD
• CPD Model – Powers  DVMS Operations
• 3D Knowledge Model – Powers the DVMS Culture
• FastTrack Model – Enables A Phased DVMS Adoption

Digital Value Management System® is a registered trademark of the DVMS Institute LLC.

® DVMS Institute 2025 All Rights Reserved